How Reddit Is Shaping AI Recommendations About Your Brand

Table of Contents
Most organizations are still treating AI visibility like a search problem.
It’s not.
It’s a reputation problem.
When a customer asks an AI assistant about your company, products, competitors, or industry, the answer isn’t generated solely from your website. It’s built from information gathered across the internet, including customer conversations happening in public forums.
One of the largest sources of those conversations is Reddit.
That means the discussions taking place there may influence how AI describes your brand long before a prospect ever visits your website.
For leaders responsible for growth, customer experience, brand reputation, and digital strategy, that changes the conversation entirely.
Your Customers Are Already Defining Your Brand
Many organizations still view Reddit as a platform they can choose to engage with or ignore.
In reality, that decision may have already been made for them.
Customers are discussing products, comparing alternatives, sharing frustrations, asking questions, and making recommendations every day. Those conversations happen whether a brand participates or not.
Reddit strategist Danny Kirk, founder of ReddiReach, has worked with hundreds of brands navigating this shift. His observation is simple:
“If they’re a big company, they are being spoken about on Reddit.”
That reality creates both a challenge and an opportunity.
The challenge is that organizations no longer have complete control over how their brand is discussed.
The opportunity is that customer conversations provide a direct window into how people actually experience products, services, and brands.
Unlike surveys or focus groups, these conversations happen voluntarily. Customers speak in their own words, reveal their concerns, compare competitors, and explain what influences their decisions.
For leaders seeking a clearer understanding of customer behavior, that information is difficult to ignore.
AI Is Learning From Customer Conversations
The growing importance of Reddit has less to do with Reddit itself and more to do with how information is being discovered.
Traditional search engines helped users find information.
AI increasingly helps users interpret information.
That’s a significant shift.
When someone asks an AI assistant to compare products, recommend a vendor, explain a company, or summarize customer sentiment, the response is often informed by conversations happening across the web.
Reddit has become one of the largest publicly available sources of those conversations.
As Kirk notes:
“Reddit is still the largest single source of training data for AI.”
Whether that percentage changes over time is less important than the larger trend.
AI systems are increasingly learning from customer conversations, not just company content.
Organizations that understand this shift early will be better positioned to influence how their brand is understood in AI-powered environments.
AI Doesn’t Just Recommend Brands. It Describes Them.
Many discussions about AI focus on discoverability.
The bigger issue may be interpretation.
Search engines historically pointed users toward information.
AI increasingly summarizes, evaluates, compares, and explains.
That means AI is shaping perception before a prospect ever reaches your website.
A potential customer may ask:
- Which vendors are best for my situation?
- What do customers think about this company?
- How does this product compare to competitors?
- What are the common complaints?
The answers generated by AI are influenced by the information available to it.
If that information is incomplete, inaccurate, or outdated, the resulting recommendations may be as well.
For executives, this is no longer just a marketing concern.
It’s a brand governance issue.
It’s a customer experience issue.
And increasingly, it’s a competitive issue.
Customer Conversations Are a Source of Strategic Intelligence
Organizations invest heavily in market research, customer surveys, focus groups, and analytics platforms.
All of those tools have value.
But customer conversations often reveal important insights long before they appear in formal reporting systems.
Questions reveal uncertainty.
Recommendations reveal trust.
Patterns reveal emerging opportunities and risks.
This idea sits at the heart of the CARE Framework, which treats customer conversations as a source of business intelligence rather than simply a source of engagement.
Conversations often contain acquisition signals, retention risks, and engagement opportunities before those trends become visible in dashboards and reports.
For enterprise organizations, that can create a meaningful advantage.
Leaders gain access to customer language, emerging concerns, and unmet expectations in real time.
Participation Matters More Than Publishing
Many brands still approach social platforms primarily as publishing channels.
Reddit rewards a different behavior.
Participation.
The most valuable interactions often happen inside comment threads where questions are answered, expertise is demonstrated, and trust is built.
As Kirk explains:
“Comments are where you can answer questions. You can chime in with helpful information.”
This distinction matters because customer trust rarely develops through promotional messaging alone.
It develops when organizations demonstrate expertise, provide value, and contribute meaningfully to conversations customers are already having.
The brands that succeed are not necessarily the brands creating the most content.
They’re the brands creating the most useful interactions.
Authenticity Is Becoming a Competitive Advantage
One of the reasons Reddit has become increasingly important is its focus on protecting authentic human participation.
The platform has invested heavily in reducing manipulation, identifying bot activity, and preserving genuine discussion.
That aligns with a broader shift happening across digital channels.
Customers increasingly trust people more than content.
They trust expertise more than promotion.
And they trust conversations more than campaigns.
For organizations, this creates an encouraging reality.
Success doesn’t require more automation.
It requires better participation.
Listen first.
Understand the community.
Provide accurate information.
Help where appropriate.
Build trust consistently.
The fundamentals are remarkably similar to effective customer care.
The Bigger Risk Is Staying Silent
Many organizations worry about participating in public conversations.
They worry about criticism.
They worry about making mistakes.
They worry about losing control.
Those concerns are understandable.
But the larger risk may be assuming silence prevents those conversations from happening.
It doesn’t.
Customers will continue discussing products.
Competitors will continue entering those discussions.
And AI will continue learning from what it finds.
As Kirk puts it:
“This is SEO 20 years ago when we all wish we would’ve started.”
The comparison resonates because it highlights a familiar pattern.
Organizations that recognized the importance of search early gained a significant advantage.
The same opportunity may exist today for organizations that understand the relationship between customer conversations, AI visibility, and brand reputation.
Building Relationships Before AI Delivers the Answer
The organizations that succeed in an AI-driven environment won’t necessarily be the ones producing the most content.
They’ll be the ones building the strongest relationships.
That starts with listening.
It grows through participation.
And it strengthens when organizations treat customer conversations as opportunities to learn rather than problems to avoid.
Reddit happens to be one of the clearest places to observe those conversations today.
But the larger lesson extends far beyond any single platform.
As AI increasingly shapes how customers discover, evaluate, and understand brands, authentic human conversations become more valuable—not less.
Organizations that participate thoughtfully won’t just improve visibility.
They’ll influence the conversations shaping future AI recommendations, uncover customer intelligence competitors may be missing, and develop a deeper understanding of the people they serve.
That may become one of the most valuable competitive advantages available.
Want to Understand What AI Is Learning About Your Brand?
The conversation about your brand is already happening.
If you’d like to understand what customers are saying, what AI may be learning from those conversations, and where those insights could create opportunities for your business, schedule a free consultation with Brooke.
Together, you’ll uncover where those conversations are happening and what they may be revealing about your brand.
Read the Transcript
[00:00:00] What you need to know about Reddit
[00:00:00]
Danny Kirk: If they’re a big company, they are being spoken about on Reddit, and just like any other marketing channel, would you rather ignore it and be not in control of that marketing channel, or would you rather be a part of the conversation?
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Hey, hey everyone, and welcome back to the Social Media CX Podcast. Before we get into it, let me set the stage for you all. Today I am joined by Danny Kirk, the founder of ReddiReach, which is a marketing agency specializing in Reddit marketing, hence ReddiReach in the name.
They do things around AI search, growth, and strategy for Reddit, and Danny has worked with over 500 brands, helping them show how showing up authentically on social, hello, like all the things we talk about, and on Reddit specifically, is increasingly helping with things like AI-driven search results that are shaping how customers find trust in your brand or just find your [00:01:00] brand.
So excited to talk to him during our full month of all AI and social media content here on the podcast. Danny, welcome to the Social Media CX Show.
Danny Kirk: Hey, Brooke, thanks for having me on.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Thanks so much for coming. I can’t tell you how many conversations we’ve been in with clients over the past, I’d say, like two years or so. The conversation around Reddit has really spiked.
So my first question is, before we get into, like, some of the deeper questions, why do you think people are just now jumping onto the Reddit bandwagon?
Danny Kirk: I think it’s because it’s, you know, for the past 20 years it’s been a very obscure corner of the internet. I think it is still a very obscure corner of the internet. Why people are interested now, and especially brand owners, some of the companies you get to work with and myself as well, is seeing their organic traffic, go off a cliff and they’re wondering where it’s going to.
And it’s likely going to AI search these days. So then they maybe dig a [00:02:00] little deeper. They hear that Reddit is a large single source of training data, and then they’re like, “Whoa, what is Reddit?”
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yes. Yeah, AI, the shiny new thing, has brought us to Reddit, which is a shiny new thing even though it’s not new.
Danny Kirk: Yeah, exactly. They’ve been around for a long time, but it’s like a new chapter for them, that’s for sure.
[00:02:21] Why enterprise brands should care about Reddit in 2026
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: So let’s start with like, a big picture question because I do think a lot of brands have a complicated relationship with Reddit. They either ignore it completely, tried it once and maybe got roasted so they didn’t stick around. I was literally teaching a class today on marketing, and some of my students were saying that they looked at Reddit as a part of the company and the product line that they work for, and they saw that it was a lot of negative conversation, right?
So they’re like, “Ooh, no, we don’t wanna go there ’cause there’s negative conversation.” So I think that happens, or they’re vaguely aware that it matters, but they just really don’t know where to start. So I think, you know, to [00:03:00] address the elephant in the room right up front, why should brands or a brand, especially if they’re an enterprise sized brand, care about Reddit right now in the year 2026?
Danny Kirk: Yep. So assuming that they’re a large company that has a bunch of customers and a lot of people talk about a couple of different reasons. First and foremost, if they’re a big company, they are being spoken about on Reddit, and just like any other marketing channel, would you rather ignore it and be not in control of that marketing channel, or would you rather be a part of the conversation?
And who knows, maybe even learn something from what is being said. Now, the second part about that is, is that Reddit is still the largest single source of training data for AI. So yet again, organic search is moving to agentic search, to AI search, and if AI is not seeing your brand, if it’s also not understanding your brand.
I ran into a brand owner the other day, who said that AI was just [00:04:00] saying false things, as we know AI does, about their brand just because it had bad information.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Mm-hmm.
Danny Kirk: The schema on their website wasn’t correct. It couldn’t read all the information. So for those two reasons, you really wanna be paying attention right now.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah, I couldn’t agree more, and I think that’s such a great foundation, especially if, like, if you’re a larger brand, which we typically work with enterprise brands for our social care services, they’ve already got those conversations happening. We always go take a peek on Reddit, and I would say nine and a half times out of 10 we find that they’re, there’s a there on Reddit for them.
So I think that’s a great foundation, and I think the business story around Reddit itself is really important context here because Reddit is finally profitable. You were telling me this when we were talking in our pre-call previous to scheduling this. The IPO happened. Google is paying, like six something like $60 million to annually license Reddit data. Hi, if Google’s paying $60 million to license
their data, it must be important. [00:05:00] Sam Altman holds a stake in Reddit stock. If you don’t know who Sam Altman is, he is one of the co-founders of OpenAI, which is ChatGPT. So it’s not a scrappy forum. Like, I think a lot of people still think it’s like, one of those, like, website forums. It’s actual infrastructure.
[00:05:17] Reddit as an AI training ground
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: So my question is, from your perspective, what does Reddit or what does Reddit’s financial maturity, like the fact that all of these things are happening with these big players in the technology space, what does that mean for brands that are still on the fence about showing up on a site like Reddit?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, absolutely. So I think about human incentives a lot. Reddit now has a business model of selling human data. That’s what they have on their platform. There’s really amazing forum of incredibly passionate people. That’s where passionate people hang out. And finally, AI comes along and wants to scrape that, and now they have a business model.
So what’s Reddit’s incentive is to keep humans on the platform, not have bots on the platform, and AI [00:06:00] company’s incentive is to keep buying that data so they can keep training their models on ever-changing human information. And yet again, since it’s the largest single source of training data, why brand owners should be caring is that if you’re not a part of that conversation or you’re not kind of steering the conversation with factually accurate information, you may just be left behind in this ever-changing time.
So that’s really why it’s important to kind of be paying attention and get the snowball building.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah. I really wanna talk about one of the things you said, or pull on the human data angle that you talked about, because what I find fascinating about Reddit from a social media customer care or social care perspective, and this, which is what we talk about on this show, is that Reddit is arguably one of the richest sources of unfiltered human conversations on the internet, if I’m not mistaken.
So we’ve got real people, because like you said, they crack down on bots, which we’ll talk about too. [00:07:00] These people have real opinions, they have real frustrations, real feelings. They’re giving real buying signals or churn signals, friction signals within those conversations, and it’s all completely unsolicited.
And now we know, as we’ve been talking about and we’ve talked about on some past episodes, AI is training on these conversations, so large language models are pulling from Reddit conversations to generate some of these AI answers, recommendations, or product comparisons. So I want you to talk to me about Reddit as an AI training ground.
With all of this human data it has and natural language processing, right, NLP is how AI works best, these are all these natural conversations that are happening. What does it mean for brands who have a presence or who don’t that Reddit is literally shaping part of what AI says about you?
Is this, like, an angle to get people to get on Reddit more quickly, or what do you think?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, absolutely. I think that it’s just that [00:08:00] people are talking about your brand, whether favorably or unfavorably on Reddit, and yet again, if it was, you know, we’re talking e-commerce brands. So say you have Google Reviews or Trustpilot or whatever other platform, imagine you know there’s a lot of reviews over there and you don’t care if they’re good or bad. No brand owner would agree with that. They’d be like, “Of course,” like, “Tell me, like, what can I do?”
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Uh-huh.
[00:08:25] How Reddit fits into your AI search strategy
Danny Kirk: Same thing, and furthermore, AI is training on those reviews effectively. So you have everyone talking about your brand, then AI is training on it. And I always tell people to kind of zoom out and imagine, you know, the next generation, younger, younger than ourselves. You know, you and I have grown up with, 10 blue links, and now we’re also seeing AI recommendations, so we’ve kind of spanned the gap. Now, the next generation that’s younger than us may never know 10 blue links, and they have an emotional relationship with their AI. Maybe they [00:09:00] take two weeks to chat through a problem they’re having, and it’s an in-depth chat.
They’ve come back 20 times, and finally it’s like, “Hey, do you want me to recommend a few products for you that might be able to solve that?” Of course they’re gonna take that recommendation over 10 blue links. It’s an emotional relationship, and also future demographic that’s younger than us is not even gonna know Google Search.
It’s only going to be AI search. So that’s why it’s really important to start that snowball now. Our demographic is, may still use Google Search as long as it’s available, but the future customers you may or may not have, are the ones that you really need to care about. And one note on Reddit, that you kinda mentioned, it’s not to say that Reddit is the only source of great human training data. It is the only open source of human training data.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Mm-hmm.
Danny Kirk: Facebook’s been around for a while. There’s a lot of brands being mentioned on Facebook. You have to have a login to see what is being said. So Reddit is totally open. You can’t comment or upvote [00:10:00] if you don’t have a account, but anybody can go in there and see the conversation, and that’s why it’s a great source of training data and has been chosen by AI to train on.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah, I love that. I mean, we tell customers who are even maybe thinking about Reddit or are like, “No, Reddit’s not for me,” at least go scrape some of the conversations that are happening there about your brand, your products, your services, your stakeholders, and come back and analyze that, because that might be a little bit of a sway for you to join the platform.
Danny Kirk: And I think it’s a good thing. You know, 90% of the people I talk to, you know, are like, “Oh, there’s a bad conversation on Reddit, about our brand.” First and foremost, it’s usually like one post out of 100, and they’re myopic on that.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Right.
Danny Kirk: And then secondly, if we’re being intellectually honest about it, wouldn’t you want to hear the feedback of your customers?
Maybe there’s an issue there. Maybe they are giving you free information to go better your product or service.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah. I mean, [00:11:00] literally, I think this is such an important part. Brands are so, like, they salivate over acquisition or gaining new customers. They don’t spend enough time on retention or retaining the customers. So if we can find out from these negative conversations what needs to be fixed, and then go and actually fix that thing, we can potentially save ourselves from losing those customers, increasing lifetime customer value, all of those cool things that we talk about on this podcast all the time.
So I love that you brought that up. You talk a lot about GEO or AEO, answer engine optimization or generative engine optimization. They all mean the same thing, right? We’re still figuring out all the acronyms around this.
Danny Kirk: Yeah. Nobody knows what to call it.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah, same concept, different names. But the idea is that brands need to optimize not just for search engines now, so not just for people.
We’ve always optimized for people. We’ve been optimizing of late for search engines, but now we need to optimize for AI answers. [00:12:00] How does Reddit specifically fit into a specific, like GEO or AEO strategy, and what do you think showing up on Reddit actually looks like when the goal is AI visibility and not just platform traffic?
[00:12:17] The next generation isn’t using Google for search
Danny Kirk: Yeah, absolutely. So Reddit, as of the current data I’ve seen, makes up roughly 20% of all citations, from AI at any one time. That is an incredibly broad generalization based on the model, based on your industry. B2C companies might have a little bit higher percentage. B2B companies might have a much lower percentage.
Let’s just call it 20%. So it’s the largest single source. Now, there’s the other 80% of things we all need to be doing to show up in AI search, but it’s the largest single source. What’s interesting about answer engine optimization or GEO is that, you know, when with Google Search, Google would only recommend things favorably.[00:13:00]
You know, you search for something and the like, 10 blue links would be like, “Hey, these are the things we recommend.” Now, if you ask AI about a brand, it may tell you something unfavorable about that brand, which is kind of interesting. So it’s not only being on there, having brand awareness on Reddit, but also shaping that sentiment as well, making sure people have factually accurate information, making sure that you’re answering people’s questions, being helpful, spreading positive brand awareness. So it’s not only just about being seen. Yet again, it’s not just Google like, let’s show up on page one. It’s more like, let’s show up on page one and have accurate information and be recommended.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: So it’s similar, it sounds like, to what we tell people with social care. Like these conversations are happening. We need you to, A, collect the voice of customer data, which is passive and still reactive. But B, we need you to join that conversation, no matter if it’s positive, neutral, or negative, and kind of help guide the narrative in the, [00:14:00] in the way you want it to go, right?
We can’t always force people into our narrative, but we might be able to gently guide the conversation, but we have to join the conversation to do that. Is that similar?
Danny Kirk: Absolutely, absolutely. Yeah, just joining the conversation, understanding what people are saying, really empathizing with what is being said is absolutely the first step.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Awesome. I want to get into something else that I think is really important that you mentioned to me, and it was honestly one of the things that really made me excited when we were talking on our pre-call, and that is that you were saying that Reddit is really cracking down on bots and automation, and that they’re actively trying to protect the integrity of human conversation in a way that most social platforms, if we’re being honest, are not doing at all.
In fact, some of them might be doing the opposite. But from a social care philosophy standpoint, this is exactly what I think how it should be, how the social ecosystem should be. So can you tell us a [00:15:00] little bit more about Reddit’s war on bots and automation, what’s happening, what are the consequences for brands that try to game that system, and, you know, why does it matter, essentially?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, absolutely. So back to incentives. Reddit’s incentive is to stay profitable, and what does that mean? They need to keep selling human data, and if they get too many bots, then that dilutes their product effectively. So they wanna get bots off their platform and keep the human conversation going. Yeah, they’ve been cracking down over the past year.
Actually, one of my predictions for 2026 was a big crackdown on bots, and that actually came in March of this year. There was a DevIt release where they allowed ironically, they fight bots with bots, so they’re allowing more bots to be put on subreddits to look for bot activity. They’re requiring accounts that they believe to be bots. They’re, actually fine with bots on their platform, but they now have to flag themselves as [00:16:00] bots. So they are actually having kind of human validation of accounts if it’s a human or if it’s a bot. Long story short, it’s easier than ever to do well on Reddit because if you’re a good actor, if you’re just doing human things, joining the conversation, being helpful, being value add, you’re gonna rise to the top.
You’re gonna look great, and everyone else that is an automation or doing things poorly is, a race to the bottom. So yeah, focusing on community, focusing on finding your tribe there, your 1,000 true fans, is what you wanna be doing.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Just makes me so excited, and I love it so much, and it leads perfectly into a little bit of something I wanna push on. Because on this show, we say it all the time, right? The brands that win on social are the ones that show up like humans. They’re not in the constant hamster wheel. It’s not about content calendars.
It’s not about distributing content any longer. It’s not about scheduling out all of your salesy [00:17:00] messages. It’s not about using bots to put out your content and answer every post that’s out there. And Reddit seems like maybe the only true platform, maybe LinkedIn a little bit secondary, but LinkedIn is a far second place.
Reddit seems to be the only platform that enforces this the most aggressively, and you’ve said you see yourselves as the good marketers on Reddit.
[00:17:25] What good marketing on Reddit actually looks like
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: So what does it actually look like in practice to be a good marketer on Reddit, and how do you separate your brand, from the ones that are racing to the bottom on Reddit?
Like, how do you, how do you become one of those brands that thrive on Reddit versus getting banned or ignored?
Danny Kirk: You know, we focus on white hat tactics. A lot of our other peers or even brands that are doing it themselves are sharing fake testimonials. They’re manipulating upvotes and downvotes. I’m not a lawyer, but that’s an FTC violation, from the counsel I’ve [00:18:00] been given.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah.
Danny Kirk: And the argument of that would be, “Oh, it’s anonymous. Nobody will ever find out.” It’s becoming easier to find out with AI and tracking and, you know, all that jazz. So not only is that unsavory and a poor way of doing marketing, in my opinion, it’s also illegal. There’s tons of companies and agencies doing that.
So we’re the exact opposite of that direction. We’re 100% human, don’t use any automations. We don’t make false claims. You know, there is no manipulation or influencing going on. We’re trying to do our best job representing the 47 companies that we represent on there. And again, that’s not hard to do. You just act like a human.
You spread factually accurate information of, about the brand with no false claims in it. You’re helpful to other people. You answer questions, and it’s gonna be a good day if you do that.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: I mean, it sounds so simple because if you’re a good actor, it is, I guess.
Danny Kirk: Yeah, [00:19:00] it definitely is. And that’s not to say that bad things can’t happen. Sometimes you’re, you get a moderator that doesn’t even follow their own rules, ’cause there’s still a human in the mix. That’s the interesting part, that each subreddit is like a little, a little nation state with kings and queens, they make their own rules, and sometimes they don’t even follow their own rules.
So, you know, I with my personal account, which I do no marketing from, I get things deleted all the time just because you know, a human has to decide, and sometimes they just don’t like what I said. So that’s not to say that bad things can’t happen. Bad things can happen on any marketing platform. But I mean, boy, Facebook and Meta, Instagram, I mean, changes all the time. It’s just focusing on doing a good job, and letting that compound over time is the way to do it.
[00:19:47] Reddit as a social care channel
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: I wanna bring things back a little bit towards social care because that’s really what we talk about on this show all the time. And I think that the way that you describe Reddit or using Reddit, you know, authentic [00:20:00] human conversations, real questions, real frustrations, real buying signals, real answers, to me it doesn’t sound like a marketing channel.
It sounds like an experience or a care channel. So in your opinion, how are the brands doing this well, actually using Reddit for customer experience? Are they just monitoring and collecting that passive voice of customer data? Are they actually also responding? Are they doing both? Are they building dedicated presence in relevant subreddits, like you were mentioning some of the subreddit?
Like, what is good social care, not just marketing, but what does good social care look like on Reddit?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, for sure. So for those big brands that do have a big presence on there, there’s conversations about them happening, whether or not they’re a part of it. They’re joining the conversation. They’re learning things from what people are saying, gathering that customer voice, and then they’re engaging with it, not only from a branded account, where they’re saying, “Hey, I’m from the brand.
How can I [00:21:00] help? Heard you had some problems. Here are some resources. What can I do?” Kind of the, the fairy godmother of the brand just floating around being helpful. But also maybe making their own subreddit, which they can be in control of sharing new product releases on there, building kind of more of a tribe. The brands that I see playing long-term games are doing things like that.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Can you just, for everybody who’s listening or watching and maybe isn’t familiar with Reddit, can you explain the difference between, like, a brand account and a personal account? Because that’s kind of a big thing on Reddit as well.
Danny Kirk: Yeah, we call it branded and non-branded. So branded account would be like Ford’s, you know, you dot forward slash Nike, you know, Nike’s account. And my personal account is something like Prestigious Leopard with some numbers behind it. I can’t even remember which one it is. It’s a randomized username that you’re assigned, and if you don’t, put a real username in there, that’s just the one you get.
So branded and non-branded. And, you know, you can do great work from both. The best brands that I [00:22:00] know of that are on there are doing both branded and non-branded activity. So, you can certainly leverage both to do Reddit marketing well.
[00:22:08] Why comments matter more than posts
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: That’s a great tip, y’all. So branded and unbranded w- ways to think about how your, your Reddit strategy should go. One of the things that I pulled from your other podcast appearances that I want to dig into is something you said around comments, and you said, “Comments matter more than posts on Reddit.”
And that got me super excited because our tagline is, “Think conversation, not campaign.” And in our social care work, we tag and code conversations and comments for things like acquisition signals, retention signals, engagement signals. And Reddit comments are some of the richest unstructured customer data that exists based on the conversations that we’ve been having.
So why are you saying comments matter more than posts on Reddit? And why or [00:23:00] what are brands missing when they focus only on publishing instead of participating in that comment layer?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, a couple different things. On the human aspect of it, when you market on Reddit, you wanna be value add, you wanna be helpful. You’re not really, you know, you’re not helpful that much in posts. Posts are kind of inherently promotional. You’re waving your hands and saying, “Hey, look at me.”
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Mm-hmm.
Danny Kirk: Comments are where you can answer questions, you can chime in with helpful information.
So you can be value add there. So that’s a reason kind of human to human to do it. And then furthermore, AI is reading comments for the human sentiment. are citing a post as the citation, but the reason why they’re citing it is because the comments in it are giving them some information about that recommendation.
So that is where AI is getting its data from, its kind of qualitative human data from.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Yeah, that makes a lot, that makes a lot of sense. Switching gears a little bit, I want to address some fears that people might [00:24:00] have around Reddit. We work with a lot of, like, highly regulated brands, and some of those brands, not all of them, but some of them immediately hear Reddit and think risk. One wrong move and we’re gonna get roasted in front of millions of people, which is honestly not just for saved for Reddit.
People think that, or brands think that a lot about social in general. But how do you, when you’re talking to brands, reframe that risk conversations for brands who are scared? And is the risk of showing up actually greater or smaller than the risk of not showing up, especially as we’ve been talking about AI pulls more and more data from Reddit?
Danny Kirk: Yeah. So, I mean, risks associated with it, all marketing channels have risks, all social channels have risk. Yet again, be a good actor on the platform. Don’t do anything illegal or shady. Be helpful, be value add. Dip your toes into it. Don’t go all out on day one. You know, kinda learn about the [00:25:00] ethos of your tribe and your subreddits that you wanna engage in on there, and I think it’s gonna be okay.
There’s a lot more details to that, but you know, just be a good actor on the platform and it’ll go well. then is there more of a risk to not do it or do it? Yet again, AI is sycophantic. It says things to please people. So if it is gonna say something about your brand, it’s gonna say something about your competitor’s brand, whether it’s really recommending or not recommending things.
So you really wanna be a part of that conversation ’cause it is gonna say something, versus, yet again, standard Google search or whatnot, it’s only recommending the top things. AI may have some misinformation about your brand and may just be spreading that around ’cause it doesn’t know any better. So I think, and yet again, with that demographic that’s younger than us that, are your future customers that only know AI search, you really wanna be thinking about them and optimizing for them.
I always say [00:26:00] this is SEO 20 years ago when we all wish we would’ve started. This is the snowball you wanna be building today.
[00:26:06] How to make the case for Reddit to leadership
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: I love that analogy and example, ’cause yes, well, you and I have been around for a long time, so I totally relate to that. I wanna go into something that’s super actionable, because, the listeners are usually, the people who listen to our audience here are practitioners. They’re social care managers, they’re CX leaders, sometimes they’re community managers or on the social team.
So they’re not necessarily decision makers all the time, but they’re the ones who have to make that case internally many times. So if someone were listening and they wanna make the case for Reddit to their stakeholders or leadership, what is one data point or argument that you think lands every time you talk about it?
Danny Kirk: Yeah, I think, yet again, just back to the AI search, [00:27:00] it’s the largest single source of training data. Their organic traffic has gone off a cliff, and they don’t know where it’s going. More people are using AI search than ever, and that’s a trend that’s gonna continue. In the future, it’s gonna be 100% the reason to get on it today is not all brands are doing it, so it’s easier than ever to start building that snowball. So that’s why the social manager should be starting that process.
[00:27:24] What most brands get wrong about Reddit
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Makes a lot of sense. Last question, and I ask this because it’s the through line of everything that we’ve been talking about on the show. What’s one thing you wish every brand understood about Reddit that almost no one gets right?
Danny Kirk: I think everyone thinks that Reddit is a bunch of trolls. The way I describe it is it’s a bunch of passionate people. Now, when you meet a passionate people, a passionate person, excuse me, they’re usually screaming from the rooftop about something. Sometimes it’s bad things, sometimes it’s good things.
Mention one [00:28:00] brand and they’re like, “Oh, that’s the worst thing on the planet.” Then mention another brand, and they’re like, “That’s the best thing on the planet.” So it’s really a great place where passionate people are. Now, we all know about 1,000 true fans. That’s like the gold mine for any brand. So I think you wanna be engaging in that conversation.
You want to be one of those brands that is understood well, that is being recommended, that has great sentiment. The only way to do that is to join the conversation. So I think that’s the one thing that’s misunderstood, and you gotta join the conversation with the passionate people.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Y’all, Danny’s saying it. It’s not just me saying think conversation, not campaign. Danny’s saying it too. Just join the conversation. So yes, just do it. Lastly, Danny, tell everybody who’s watching or listening where they can find you, how they can connect with you, where they can find out more about ReddiReach, all those things.
Danny Kirk: Yeah, absolutely. Our website is reddireach.com. [00:29:00] And then I’m very active on LinkedIn, so you type in Danny Kirk, Reddi Reach, or my handle is Daniel P as in Patrick Kirk, and you’ll find me on there. Feel free to reach out. Always happy to chat and give my kinda quick take on your brand.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Awesome. Thank you so much for joining today, us today, and giving us the Reddit rundown. I think, like I said, I’ve just seen a massive uptick the past couple of years in Reddit, should we, shouldn’t we? So I love that you are here to kind of drop all of your wisdom and experience on us so that we can make better decisions and just join the conversation.
Danny Kirk: Yeah. Thanks for having me, Brooke.
Brooke Sellas | B Squared Media: Thank you.
Reddit isn’t a risk to manage if you listen to all of the wonderful things that Danny just told us. It’s actually just a conversation that’s already happening. People are on there talking about your brand, your products, your industry, and they’re doing it whether you’re in the room or not.
[00:30:00] And increasingly, as Danny mentioned, the conversations that are happening on Reddit are the conversations that AI is learning from. So I think the question isn’t whether or not to show up, it’s whether you’re going to show up as a human or let the bot show up for you, and then maybe what’s the point if that’s gonna happen.
And hey, if you wanna hear what our clients are doing on Reddit, go ahead and book a free chat with me, and I’m happy to discuss with you further. Simply head on over to bsquared.media/chat and book some time with me. And as always, you know what I’m gonna say, if this show is helping you think differently about customer experience, social media, AI, please rate and review us.
It helps me bring on more brilliant guests like Danny and keeps our community growing with intention. Until next time, think conversation, [00:31:00] not campaign.
Want to hear the full conversation? Listen to the Social Media CX Podcast on YouTube. And if your team is thinking about what responsible social listening in banking or financial services actually looks like at scale, check out the State of Social Care Report 2026.
Finally, as always, Think conversation, not campaign.™
Latest posts by Brooke B. Sellas (See All)
- How Reddit Is Shaping AI Recommendations About Your Brand - July 1, 2026
- Why Most Brands Misread Social Media Engagement - June 24, 2026
- The Churn Signals Hidden in Customer Complaints - June 17, 2026
Written by award-winning strategist Brooke Sellas, this weekly 5-minute power-up will help you turn social interactions into loyalty, retention, and revenue.












